How to make longer challenges
Most challenges will be a single move, but many spots also offer opportunities to create longer challenges with several movements. With different solutions and several aspects of movement to work on, these challenges can suit a wider range of skill levels and offer a richer, more rewarding experience.
Two approaches that help to make longer challenges
1. Make the rules and goals clear while leaving the movement solution open.
Floor-is-lava challenges and climbing routes are good examples. Define the start, the finish and what people may touch along the way, without showing the solution.
You can also show a starting position and an ending position, leaving people to figure out how to move between them.
2. Link movements so that each movement affects the next.
The momentum and body position from one movement should affect how people can perform the next.
This creates several opportunities for improvement: the first movement, the transition and the movement that follows.
Things to avoid
Resets between linked movements
If people can reset their momentum and position so that the previous movement no longer affects the next, the movements may work just as well as separate challenges.
Filler sections in floor-is-lava challenges
If two interesting sections are connected by a long filler section, consider making them separate challenges.
Two things can make filler sections bad:
- Areas that break the experience.Places to stand and rest can be fine. However, large, flat areas or sections very close to the ground can make it stop feeling like a floor-is-lava challenge.
- Long stretches of awkward or unrewarding movement.This can be repetitive climbing that forces people to scrape their face, clothes or other body parts along a wall, or precise movements that do not feel satisfying, like walking along the bottom of a fence where there is not much space for the feet.
This does not mean that you should avoid long challenges of strength and endurance. Just make them clear and satisfying.
Large difficulty gaps
Avoid large differences in difficulty within the challenge.
If one part is too easy compared with the rest: It should only be included if it is satisfying or an important connector between two parts that feel like they belong together.
If one part is too hard compared with the rest: It will discourage people from attempting the challenge, even though the rest of the challenge is perfect for them.
Reviewing a challenge using these concepts
This challenge works well even though it offers two opportunities to reset. Here’s why:
1. The reset opportunities are not that bad.
For the first opportunity, when landing on the wall, it is actually easier to continue the challenge than to stop and stay there. For the second opportunity, hanging from the wall requires effort, so people still feel engaged in the challenge while hanging.
2. The challenge also has several strengths that make up for the opportunities to reset.
- It involves arm strength, which often gets too little attention in a collection of challenges.
- The two jumps are similar in difficulty.
- It makes good use of the spot’s unique features.